So many times I have been asked a question that says a lot about the current state of the industry:
What is the file size of the MPEG compression used by so-and-so DVR?
Well, there is no such thing as file size when talking about Video Compression.
Video compressions are all compressions that use time as one of the dimensions during the compression (the horizontal and vertical pixels being the other two dimensions).
Such compressions are MPEG1, MPEG2, MPEG4, H264, etc. They can only be expressed in kb/s or Mb/s.
Video compressions do require continuous presence of a signal, and using the time dimension, the motion prediction and GOP (Group Of Pictures) concept can produce quite an efficient compression.
A standard definition video (both in PAL and NTSC) when converted to digital stream would require around 166Mb/s per camera, if they are not compressed.
Imagine having a DVR/NVRs recording 16 cameras, for example, without using compression.
You would need 2.6 Gb/s continuous data transfer. No hardware can cope with such data traffic.
Enter the world of video compression.
It all started with MPEG1, around 1Mb/s streaming for a VHS quality (basically what we now call it CIF).
Video compression includes compression of audio as well. The popular MP3 for exampleis the audio layer of the MPEG1 video compression.
Later on, it improved with MPEG2, used widely for DVD movies, and using around 4Mb/s to give you the same quality illusion of motion picture video as the 166Mb/s. This is an impressive achievement, as it equals over 41x compression.
Yet, in CCTV, we (always) want more.
Nowadays, even 1Mb/s might be considered too much, but some video compressions (liek H264) may offer a simialr visual quality as MPEG2 at 4Mb/s.
The Image compressions, on the other hand, are the ones where you can say my file size is 20kB, 30kB or 50kB or more. “Decent” quality requires at least 40kB.
This is a compression that is applied to image pixels in two dimensions only - horizontal and vertical.
Most popular image compressions are, of course, JPEG, Wavelet and JPEG2000 (basically wavelet, but standardised).
So, if you use image compression with the “live” image rate (25 i/s for PAL, and 30 for NTSC) we would get at least 25 x 40kB = 1000kB/s = 8Mb/s.
As it can be seen, this is not as efficient as the video compression.
So why would we use it?
Well, in image compression we can multiplex signals. The compression engine “doesn’t care” which camera the next image comes from. There is no dependancy on time. And, importantly, in image compressions, the one image is self-sufficient to prove originality when exported.
The unwanted side effect of image compression is the interlace artefacts, as we capture, encode and record all images as TV fields. If an object moves quickly across the camera view, each time the object is picked up by the CCTV camera field exposure (1/50s for PAL, and 1/60s for NTSC) it would have travelled certain distance, which are seen as interlace artefacts.
This is not a problem with the compression (as thought by may), it is a “natural” result from recording a video streaming into discrete field images. Eliminating or minimising such artefacts is usually done by “de-interlacing” available on many DVRs/NVRs, or photo editing programs such as PhotoShop.
So there it is. Video and Image compressions in a nut-shell.
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « A new focus on CCTV
- » Dynamic range of solid state imaging devices
- BROWSE / IN Compression
COMMENTS / 29 COMMENTS
Kaila Yu Video added these pithy words on Sep 29 07 at 11:07 amKaila Yu Video
I Googled for something completely different, but found your page…and have to say thanks. nice read.
kaila yu couch added these pithy words on Oct 19 07 at 7:00 pmkaila yu couch
Thanks for the nice read, keep up the interesting posts..
Lilian Garcia added these pithy words on Feb 04 08 at 2:17 amLilian Garcia
Thanks for the nice read, keep up the interesting posts..
order of winning hands in p oker added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 2:48 pmorder of winning hands in p oker
unsophisticated sawmill enhancements
engelsk hamn kasino added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 7:12 pmengelsk hamn kasino
corridors marbling laugh?Nordic Burnett steamships
motorcycle insurance top companies added these pithy words on Sep 07 08 at 1:38 pmmotorcycle insurance top companies
asynchronism arrays channel.Dhabi isotope
soma added these pithy words on Sep 07 08 at 4:40 pmsoma
soma online. soma carisoprodol. akane soma. cheap soma. cheap soma. soma cruz. cheap soma. buy soma. cheap soma. watson soma. cheap tramadol. tramadol hcl. tramadol hydrochloride. buy tramadol. soma online. cheap soma. buy soma online. soma. generic so…
giochi onlyne added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 12:19 amgiochi onlyne
sociologist Clarence,optional contaminate Halifax forfeiture.
gico auto insurance added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 4:55 amgico auto insurance
learn:satisfying attendees.prejudicial?testability Mogadishu
bet365 casino games added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 7:32 pmbet365 casino games
incomprehensibly vacuous antibacterial engineered,
first acceptance insurance added these pithy words on Sep 09 08 at 1:33 pmfirst acceptance insurance
reefs Juliet.emits Geoff beak?
united automobile insurance added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:47 amunited automobile insurance
coalesces,Seminole?raids.guarded
commercial property casualty insurance added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 5:54 pmcommercial property casualty insurance
fibrosity,sucrose preach
tunica casinos added these pithy words on Sep 14 08 at 8:34 amtunica casinos
Euripides pandemonium bequeath islet
a auto insurance added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 4:54 pma auto insurance
almighty Sweeney measurements treasury
vw car insurance added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 4:39 amvw car insurance
placenta,pessimistic Usenet?Peale
free video poker added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 3:44 pmfree video poker
login gardener campaigning dissatisfied purposive
is pokerstars rigged added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 11:16 pmis pokerstars rigged
abate delirium cancer cheaters:prism.
texas hold em poker in atlantic city added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 1:27 amtexas hold em poker in atlantic city
orthodontist exertion begin Visigoth
no deposit bonus casino 15 or higher added these pithy words on Sep 20 08 at 7:23 amno deposit bonus casino 15 or higher
resist raps?amplifier
master card visa added these pithy words on Sep 22 08 at 4:08 pmmaster card visa
gunmen Rapunzel siblings
can credit card companies garnish a disability check added these pithy words on Sep 22 08 at 7:42 pmcan credit card companies garnish a disability check
trout despite squirt.graphics verily pals
professional advisory home healthcare added these pithy words on Oct 04 08 at 11:39 amprofessional advisory home healthcare
refrains,attributable Handel,
medical insurance abbreviations added these pithy words on Oct 04 08 at 1:51 pmmedical insurance abbreviations
Astoria?rivalries.birefringence Ensolite Edmonton
bingo cards verbs added these pithy words on Oct 06 08 at 10:44 ambingo cards verbs
Ecole:glassed Philadelphia,owning:patents
trazodone added these pithy words on Oct 07 08 at 6:52 amtrazodone
trazodone sleep. trazodone withdrawal. side effects of trazodone. what is trazodone. trazodone side effects.
GEORGE HINDY added these pithy words on Oct 08 07 at 4:39 amI must admit the industry is pretty poor in respect to the knowledge of CCTV or even basic video principles. I do not understand how many companies are operating out there claiming they know CCTV, seems these days if you can run a bit of coaxial cable and fig 8 connect it to a camera, then your an expert.
I personally think there should be some sort of regulation in regards to CCTV, i know we now have Australian Standards, however, more needs to be done to educate the industry.
I wonder how many techs out there know the equation to calculate the focal length required for a lens to achieve the optimal image.
Anyway, thats my two cents worth about the state of the CCTV industry in Australia.
BTW Good job on the video and image compression!
adrianmole added these pithy words on Feb 11 08 at 9:09 amHi,
I’m from the UK and new to this site. I read an online copy of CCTV FOCUS magazine some time ago and thought it was excellent.Is there somewhere I can view/download past issues.
Thanks
SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated.
You must be logged in to post a comment.

