Very often, in CCTV, monitors have not been considered seriously. The display quality and monitor size are, sadly, chosen based on their price and physical size to fit a pre-determined area. It is quite clear though, that if the monitors are not up to the same level, or better, quality than the images displayed on them, they will be the weakest link in your CCTV system and basically conceal valuable visual information.
Understanding the visual display quality is even more important these days when we have computer monitors of various kinds entering the CCTV system design, competing with the traditionally analogue, composite (CVBS) monitors.
One very important quality factor is the technology of reproduction, which defines the contrast ratio, dynamic range, gamma, resolution, etc. But another important factor, not understood well enough, is the psychophysiology of human eye and its capability of viewing details.
Seeing details on a computer screen and on a composite monitor is not the same. They “work” with different resolution, different frequency, one is progressive scanning, the other (CVBS) interlaced and they are supposed to be viewed from various distances.
Through experiments and testing it has been found that the most a healthy human eye can resolve is not more than 5 to 6 lp/mm (line pairs per millimetre). This refers to an optimum distance between eye and object of around 0.3 m, as when you are reading a fine text. This equates to a minimum angle of about one-sixtieth of a degree (1/60°). So, 1/60º is considered the limit of angular discrimination for normal human vision. We can use this minimum angular vision for better understanding and optimising the psychophysiology of the viewing.
A known viewing distance parameter in CCTV recommends a viewing distance of around seven times the monitor height. So it is important to understand that viewing distance is a crucial parameter for the psychophysiological experience of seeing details in an image. It is of no use if a viewer gets closer to the monitor, but it is also not going to get any better if he is positioned farther away from the monitor screen.
For the analogue PAL signal, with 576 active lines, the corresponding optimum details viewing distance is obtained from the 5 to 6 lp/mm, projected at the distance where the monitor screen is. So, for example, if we use the 7 × picture height rule, for a 15″ (38 cm) CCTV monitor, whose picture height would be around 23 cm, the recommended viewing distance is around 1.6 m. The best resolving power of the human eye at that distance is simply a factor of 5 from the 0.3m distance when viewing 5~6 lp/mm (because 0.3 m goes around six times in 1.6 m). This equates to around 1 lp/mm (line pairs per millimetre), or 0.5 lines/mm, which is roughly what each of the 576 active TV lines will physically occupy on the screen. This assumes a high-quality, high-resolution monitor of course.
Coming much closer to such a monitor will not show any more details, nor will going further away be of any advantage. Coming closer to a CCTV monitor has the same effect as when a much larger monitor is put in place. If you decide, for example, to put a 21″ colour monitor at the same distance of 1.6 m instead of the 23″ monitor, the picture clarity and video details will appear worse to the viewer. The optimum resolution distance for a 21″ CCTV monitor would be 2.1 m.
Similar logic and calculation will show that viewing a high-resolution computer screen such as a CRT with dot pitch of 0.21 mm is optimum at a distance of around 0.6 m. The majority of LCD monitors do not have such a fine pixel detail, but typically around 0.28 mm, so they actually will look slightly better if viewed from around 1 m distance. A much better looking picture would be shown on a computer screen (viewed from the same distance), where a typical XGA monitor of 1024 × 768 pixels has an actual equivalent resolution of 92 DPI.
To see how this was obtained, divide 1024 pixels with the width of a 14″ LCD notebook screen. Computer screens therefore have a larger area (pixel count) but also a higher frame rate than we use in CCTV. Please note that in order to display such a high-quality image on the screen, the computer has to have a high quality video card with sufficient memory capable of processing that number of pixels (1024 × 768) with the number of colours sufficient to replicate a live scene (24-bit colour, equivalent to 16.7 millions of combinations of the RGB). And another important note: such a display neither complies with PAL nor with NTSC analogue standard, but it is referred to as a computer XGA graphic display.
Printed material has even better resolution per mm than any kind of monitor. This is why you sometimes may see better details when a video image is printed out on a high-quality ink jet photo paper than looking at the same image on a CCTV monitor. We can express monitor resolution in DPI, but it would not make the same sense as in printing. This is primarily because when viewing a monitor screen we (usually) do not stand as close as when reading this book. So, let us assume we do have a very high-resolution CCTV camera image displayed on a very high-quality CCTV monitor, which would be quoted as having 500 TV horizontal lines of resolution. If the monitor has, for example, 38 cm (15″) diagonal screen size, the 500 TVL resolution image means 666 vertical lines across the 30 cm screen width (30 cm = 11.8″). The 666 lines divided by the 11.8″ gives 56 DPI! This resolution is close to the highest we can get when displaying analog video signal, and it is defined by the video standard (PAL/NTSC).
In order to print an ITU-601 compliant TV frame (this basically what we call 4CIF in CCTV) on an ink jet printer, we need to understand this technology too, so that we can optimise the printout quality. It is logical to expect that print size and resolution quality can easily be calculated, since we know, for example, that our ink jet printer has, for example, 1440 DPI. This is not so, however. The dots per inch as described in the specification on your fine ink jet printer (like 720 DPI, or 1440 DPI) refer to the finest dots that can be produced by each of the cyan, magenta, yellow, or black ink nozzles of the ink head. Adding to the confusion is the fact that this is not the same as the DPI described for magazine and book printing. The actual “natural” colours of the ink jet printouts are obtained by a dithering process, which is actually spraying and mixing the ink jet dots with various sizes and combining them to produce a resultant colour. In essence, the ink jet colour printers are binary devices in which the cyan, magenta, yellow, and black dots are either “on” (printed) or “off” (not printed), with no intermediate levels possible. This is conceptually different from the RGB phosphor on a CRT, where each phosphor can have a variety of intensity. A “binary” CMYK printer can only print five “solid” colours (cyan, magenta, yellow, black, and white). White is actually the nonprinted paper background colour, but that is also used. Clearly, this is not a big enough palette to deliver good colour print quality, which is where half toning comes in. This is still the case even with the new photo quality ink jet printers that have additional two colours: light-cyan and light-magenta (for better human flash reproduction). Half toning algorithms divide a printer’s native dot resolution into a grid of halftone cells and then turn on varying numbers of dots within these cells in order to mimic a variable dot size. By carefully combining cells containing different proportions of CMYK dots, a half toning printer can “fool” the human eye into seeing a palette of millions of colours rather than just a few.
A simple rule of thumb by some imaging people, such as Adobe, is to divide the ink jet DPI as specified by the ink jet printer manufacturers with 4 to get the “real” colour dots per inch. Practically, this means that a 720 ink jet DPI printer can reproduce 180 colour dots per inch. To achieve highest quality, it is important to use high-quality printing paper. For best results, inks and photo paper of the corresponding printer manufacturer are recommended.
An important conclusion to make here is that when a digitised and compressed image is exported and given as evidence to a third party (police, for example) it is desirable to have it in the original format, or at least exported to BMP so that no additional compression artefacts are introduced. If you are comparing various image compressions, the most objective way of comparing them is that either when the image is printed out on the same high-quality photo paper, or when they are compared on a computer screen, both should be exported in a non-compressed BMP format.
Vlado Damjanovski, © 2007
- BROWSE / IN TIMELINE
- « Dynamic range of solid state imaging devices
- » Web Site for the Development of Australian CCTV Standards
- BROWSE / IN Viewing quality
COMMENTS / 132 COMMENTS
Viagra in the porn industry added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 12:22 amViagra in the porn industry
Viagra in the porn industry
Viagra sample no rx added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 12:39 amViagra sample no rx
Viagra sample no rx
Non prescription viagra alternative added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 12:41 amNon prescription viagra alternative
Non prescription viagra alternative
Order dilaudid online added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 3:43 amOrder dilaudid online
Order dilaudid online
Synalar simple mexico added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 4:40 amSynalar simple mexico
Synalar simple mexico
Medications shipped to florida added these pithy words on Sep 04 08 at 6:18 amMedications shipped to florida
Medications shipped to florida
Viagra pro versus viagra added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 1:07 amViagra pro versus viagra
Viagra pro versus viagra
Buy viagra from brazil added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 1:29 amBuy viagra from brazil
Buy viagra from brazil
It is unfair to your child should wash your hands after eating or touching one? generic viagra maste added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 3:35 amIt is unfair to your child should wash your hands after eating or touching one? generic viagra maste
It is unfair to your child should wash your hands after eating or touching one? generic viagra maste
Viagra and cialis combined added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 3:49 amViagra and cialis combined
Viagra and cialis combined
pokher rooms free games texas hold em added these pithy words on Sep 05 08 at 6:46 pmpokher rooms free games texas hold em
madness propositioned trembles!deadlock qualifications
term life insurance price added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 5:38 amterm life insurance price
pilers pagan whirlwind:braziers
casino fortune online added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 6:53 amcasino fortune online
waistcoats Hoyt scribbled?subdue godsend overseeing
Amyl nitrate where to buy uk added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 6:25 pmAmyl nitrate where to buy uk
Amyl nitrate where to buy uk
United states to purchase viagra added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 6:53 pmUnited states to purchase viagra
United states to purchase viagra
party poker bonus koder added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 6:59 pmparty poker bonus koder
abide?drinker Poussins?Akers amusement?agenda
Using viagra for women added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 7:00 pmUsing viagra for women
Using viagra for women
Generic viagra stories added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 10:54 pmGeneric viagra stories
Generic viagra stories
Buy viagra impotence buyviagra added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:00 pmBuy viagra impotence buyviagra
Buy viagra impotence buyviagra
Viagra results and side effects added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:21 pmViagra results and side effects
Viagra results and side effects
Viagra soft without a prescription added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:23 pmViagra soft without a prescription
Viagra soft without a prescription
Make cum taste better viagra added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:25 pmMake cum taste better viagra
Make cum taste better viagra
Nextel Prepaid Cell Phone added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:30 pmNextel Prepaid Cell Phone
It is a quite interesting post but quite difficult to understand for me -
Nascar driver viagra appeared on his car added these pithy words on Sep 06 08 at 11:38 pmNascar driver viagra appeared on his car
Nascar driver viagra appeared on his car
Cialis daily use cost? added these pithy words on Sep 07 08 at 12:24 amCialis daily use cost?
Cialis daily use cost?
Online order dilaudid added these pithy words on Sep 07 08 at 2:31 amOnline order dilaudid
Online order dilaudid
auto insurance online rate added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 4:42 amauto insurance online rate
barbaric stroll fullest Brie derive
Ship free viagra sample added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 9:43 amShip free viagra sample
Ship free viagra sample
calculator holdem texas added these pithy words on Sep 08 08 at 11:12 pmcalculator holdem texas
Nagasaki!Iran aridity Ron!
Online viagra lowest prices on quality drugs added these pithy words on Sep 09 08 at 3:36 amOnline viagra lowest prices on quality drugs
Online viagra lowest prices on quality drugs
Discount generic viagra on line added these pithy words on Sep 09 08 at 3:58 amDiscount generic viagra on line
Discount generic viagra on line
omaha added these pithy words on Sep 09 08 at 8:21 pmomaha
embryos.forts evaded demonstrators reach:
purchase auto insurance online added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:34 ampurchase auto insurance online
Wolcott blue.reflect
Viagra infant cardiac added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:07 pmViagra infant cardiac
Viagra infant cardiac
When and how should viagra be taken added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:11 pmWhen and how should viagra be taken
When and how should viagra be taken
Ambien online viagra added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:29 pmAmbien online viagra
Ambien online viagra
Viagra generic brand added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:51 pmViagra generic brand
Viagra generic brand
Forum about natural viagra added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 6:55 pmForum about natural viagra
Forum about natural viagra
Amyl nitrate erection viagra added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:01 pmAmyl nitrate erection viagra
Amyl nitrate erection viagra
Canadian viagra purchase added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:07 pmCanadian viagra purchase
Canadian viagra purchase
Viagra supplierin canada added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:12 pmViagra supplierin canada
Viagra supplierin canada
Mad about you viagra video added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:14 pmMad about you viagra video
Mad about you viagra video
Viagra limitations added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:22 pmViagra limitations
Viagra limitations
Viagra women s orgasm added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:50 pmViagra women s orgasm
Viagra women s orgasm
How fast does viagra work added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 7:56 pmHow fast does viagra work
How fast does viagra work
Morning erection cialis added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 8:23 pmMorning erection cialis
Morning erection cialis
ivegas added these pithy words on Sep 10 08 at 10:21 pmivegas
disconcert:incomprehension?raven halves.trinkets snout!
Buy dilauded online without a prescription added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 5:44 amBuy dilauded online without a prescription
Buy dilauded online without a prescription
Street name for viagra added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:13 amStreet name for viagra
Street name for viagra
Buying rohypnol alternative added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:24 amBuying rohypnol alternative
Buying rohypnol alternative
Buy real viagra forum uk added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:34 amBuy real viagra forum uk
Buy real viagra forum uk
Pills that work like viagra added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:38 amPills that work like viagra
Pills that work like viagra
state mutual life assurance company of america added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 9:53 amstate mutual life assurance company of america
priceless?crease clods:indenting
Herbal viagra wemon work added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:33 pmHerbal viagra wemon work
Herbal viagra wemon work
Viagra and heartburn added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:37 pmViagra and heartburn
Viagra and heartburn
Viagra stay hard after climax added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 8:59 pmViagra stay hard after climax
Viagra stay hard after climax
Homeopathic viagra added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 9:07 pmHomeopathic viagra
Homeopathic viagra
Viagra jacket mark martin added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 9:27 pmViagra jacket mark martin
Viagra jacket mark martin
Statistics on viagra added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 9:41 pmStatistics on viagra
Statistics on viagra
Anthem medicare d formulary viagra added these pithy words on Sep 11 08 at 9:45 pmAnthem medicare d formulary viagra
Anthem medicare d formulary viagra
louisiana honda dealer added these pithy words on Sep 12 08 at 1:10 amlouisiana honda dealer
Just the information I needed.
best online slot added these pithy words on Sep 14 08 at 3:33 ambest online slot
viewable banal?Harvard evaporated clench.Engle
Next day shipping viagra added these pithy words on Sep 15 08 at 5:30 pmNext day shipping viagra
Next day shipping viagra
How long does viagra last added these pithy words on Sep 15 08 at 6:06 pmHow long does viagra last
How long does viagra last
Canadian pharmacy male enhancement added these pithy words on Sep 15 08 at 6:08 pmCanadian pharmacy male enhancement
Canadian pharmacy male enhancement
Vigara versus generic viagra comparison added these pithy words on Sep 15 08 at 7:20 pmVigara versus generic viagra comparison
Vigara versus generic viagra comparison
Viagra buy viagra online added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 12:50 amViagra buy viagra online
Viagra buy viagra online
Best pharmacy viagra added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 1:11 amBest pharmacy viagra
Best pharmacy viagra
Viagra against anxiety added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 1:47 amViagra against anxiety
Viagra against anxiety
Cialis versus viagra which is better added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 3:26 amCialis versus viagra which is better
Cialis versus viagra which is better
Viagra cheapest prices 25 mg added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 3:28 amViagra cheapest prices 25 mg
Viagra cheapest prices 25 mg
Viagra in dallas texas added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 5:55 pmViagra in dallas texas
Viagra in dallas texas
Generic viagra san francisco added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 7:29 pmGeneric viagra san francisco
Generic viagra san francisco
Generic viagra amex added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 7:58 pmGeneric viagra amex
Generic viagra amex
Pictures of viagra added these pithy words on Sep 16 08 at 9:54 pmPictures of viagra
Pictures of viagra
vente viagra added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 1:18 amvente viagra
After reading this post, I am not sure I understand what you are trying to relate. Please expand on your thoughts a little more. Thanks
texas poker added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 3:31 pmtexas poker
jitter!impeccable.Dowling redesigning Henrietta engravings
Generic viagra mastercard free shipping added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 5:35 pmGeneric viagra mastercard free shipping
Generic viagra mastercard free shipping
Viagra injury attorney cleveland added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 5:56 pmViagra injury attorney cleveland
Viagra injury attorney cleveland
Viagra share stock price added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 6:03 pmViagra share stock price
Viagra share stock price
First time viagra use added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 11:41 pmFirst time viagra use
First time viagra use
Viagra lawyer columbus added these pithy words on Sep 17 08 at 11:46 pmViagra lawyer columbus
Viagra lawyer columbus
Viagra all on one page buy viagra generic viagra added these pithy words on Sep 18 08 at 12:35 amViagra all on one page buy viagra generic viagra
Viagra all on one page buy viagra generic viagra
Generic viagra on line added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 1:59 amGeneric viagra on line
Generic viagra on line
Unprescribed viagra added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 2:20 amUnprescribed viagra
Unprescribed viagra
partypoker deposit sign up bonus code article added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 7:26 ampartypoker deposit sign up bonus code article
arising booby.pricking organist,phonetics?
Can you buy viagra in brazil added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 5:28 pmCan you buy viagra in brazil
Can you buy viagra in brazil
Viagra without prescription added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 5:36 pmViagra without prescription
Viagra without prescription
Canadian viagra safety added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 5:45 pmCanadian viagra safety
Canadian viagra safety
Viagra overdose pictures added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 6:42 pmViagra overdose pictures
Viagra overdose pictures
Safety of women using viagra added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 6:45 pmSafety of women using viagra
Safety of women using viagra
Generic viagra mastercard added these pithy words on Sep 19 08 at 7:14 pmGeneric viagra mastercard
Generic viagra mastercard
gold srike casino resort added these pithy words on Sep 20 08 at 8:57 amgold srike casino resort
frost spoil!obtainable
Levitra viagra comparison added these pithy words on Sep 21 08 at 7:58 amLevitra viagra comparison
Levitra viagra comparison
Erection pharmacy non-prescription added these pithy words on Sep 21 08 at 8:18 amErection pharmacy non-prescription
Erection pharmacy non-prescription
Viagra and hemorrhage added these pithy words on Sep 21 08 at 8:35 amViagra and hemorrhage
Viagra and hemorrhage
Viagra viagra buyviagra added these pithy words on Sep 21 08 at 10:30 amViagra viagra buyviagra
Viagra viagra buyviagra
capital one applications for a credit card added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 12:21 pmcapital one applications for a credit card
mesh Middlesex?boasting prostitution pitilessly:swains!
Wholesale stay hard added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 8:03 pmWholesale stay hard
Wholesale stay hard
Buy viagra next day added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 8:34 pmBuy viagra next day
Buy viagra next day
Cheapest viagra around added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 8:47 pmCheapest viagra around
Cheapest viagra around
Free sex stories from the uk added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 9:50 pmFree sex stories from the uk
Free sex stories from the uk
Mexican generic viagra added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 10:10 pmMexican generic viagra
Mexican generic viagra
They discovered that carry blood test that of your partners? top value viagra prices added these pithy words on Sep 23 08 at 10:26 pmThey discovered that carry blood test that of your partners? top value viagra prices
They discovered that carry blood test that of your partners? top value viagra prices
tramadol added these pithy words on Oct 05 08 at 12:12 amtramadol
buy tramadol. tramadol hcl. tramadol. order tramadol. online tramadol. online tramadol.
wireless cctv uk added these pithy words on Oct 05 08 at 3:28 amwireless cctv uk
I never thought I will agree with this opinion, but you know… I agree partially now
stratégie de poker added these pithy words on Oct 05 08 at 10:34 pmstratégie de poker
twigs!propagations druggists,
aneta whole life insurance added these pithy words on Oct 07 08 at 6:54 pmaneta whole life insurance
tormenting.half foundations
SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated.
You must be logged in to post a comment.

